top of page

The Day After the Magic

6 days ago
13 min read
Hotel Toasters , how many more times.
Hotel Toasters , how many more times.

Confessions of a Travelling Storyteller(Part 3)


One night you have a room hanging on your every word. The next morning you’re standing in a hotel dining room, wondering whether breakfast is included.

There’s a fair distance between those two versions of yourself.

Last night, you could raise an eyebrow and have people laughing. You could lower your voice and feel a room lean towards you. This morning, you’re peering at a conveyor-belt toaster, wondering how many trips through the machine a slice of bread requires before it becomes toast.

You put it through again and it emerges looking as though it heard a rumour about warmth.

Meanwhile, somewhere between packing up the night before and finding your way downstairs, the magic has wandered off.

You’re tired. A bit hollow. Oddly sad, considering you’ve just done something you love, perhaps even done it rather well. You should be delighted. Grateful. Full of beans and ready to tell the world what a wonderful life this is.

Instead, you’re wondering whether you can take your coffee back upstairs and avoid being a human for another hour.

Welcome to the day after the magic.

It’s a part of performing I don’t often know how to explain. Particularly when somebody has just said, “You must absolutely love what you do.”

I do and that’s part of the trouble.

When a show goes well, I don’t merely enjoy it. I feel it everywhere. And when it’s over, I feel that too.

There are nights when everything comes together so beautifully that I’d happily stay there until somebody turned the lights out and physically removed me.

The audience arrives carrying whatever their day has given them. Work, worry, an argument in the car, the lingering suspicion that their partner has dragged them along to something involving audience participation.

Then we begin.

It takes a little time. We look at one another. I offer something, they decide whether they trust me with their evening, and somewhere along the way the room changes.

I can feel it when it happens.

A laugh loosens something. A face that was politely waiting becomes interested. Someone settles back, someone else leans forward, and suddenly we’re away.

The story finds its feet. Characters I’ve known for years arrive with something new to say. A line comes out differently because of the expression on somebody’s face. A pause lasts longer because the silence feels right.

I stop trying to make the performance happen and find myself inside it.

That’s a glorious place to be.

On those nights, even things going wrong somehow go right. A door bangs at a particularly dramatic moment. Somebody drops a glass. A voice calls out, and instead of breaking the spell it gives us something to play with.

I follow it. They follow me. We discover a wee moment that couldn’t have happened with any other gathering of people.

You can rehearse a story until you know every corner of it, but you can’t rehearse that.

It belongs to the room.

And I think that’s what I love most: the feeling that we’re making something together. I might be the large Scotsman doing most of the talking, but I’m certainly not doing all the work.

They give me the courage to linger. They show me when to move. Their laughter changes my timing; their stillness lets me know when a moment has landed.

And to this day I sometimes look out and think, “Aye. I can do this, This is good.”

All the driving, preparation, emails and doubt have brought me to this room, where a group of strangers has agreed to imagine something with me.

I don’t take that lightly.

Eventually, of course, the evening has to end. There’s a final story, a thank-you, applause. People stretch, gather coats, remember where they parked.

I’m still ready for another hour.

Apparently the audience has responsibilities. Babysitters. Early starts. A perfectly reasonable desire to go home.

Very inconsiderate of them.

There are conversations afterwards, and I love those too. Somebody wants to share a memory. Somebody tells me about their grandfather, or a place in Scotland, or a story they haven’t thought about since childhood.

I’m reminded that while I was telling one thing, they were remembering something else entirely.

Then the conversations thin out. The room empties. Chairs scrape across the floor.

I gather my belongings, search the stage for the numerous water bottles I’ve scattered everywhere, and then prepare to exit stage left.

A little while ago, we had ghosts at the door and whole worlds in our heads. Now somebody’s asking whether this extension lead is mine.

The change can be rather abrupt.

Even after I’ve left, there’s usually a while when I’m still buzzing. I’m tired, but I couldn’t sleep if you paid me. Bits of conversation come back. I remember a laugh, a face, a moment that surprised me.

Then, somewhere on the drive or back in the room, another voice joins in.

“Well,” it says, “shall we discuss what you could have done better?”

Ah. There he is.

The wee critic. Never misses a show. Never buys a ticket, either. The wee Sh**e.

You’d think a wonderful performance might earn me a night off from him. Let the man enjoy himself. He’s done his work, people seemed happy, nobody demanded a refund or chased him out with a broom.

But there’s always something.

I rushed the opening. I could have given that character more room. The second story might have worked better before the first. Did I talk too much between tales?

And what about that fellow near the back?

Everyone else appeared to be enjoying themselves, but he looked doubtful.

Perhaps he was tired. Perhaps he was concentrating. Perhaps he’d eaten something unfortunate and was quietly negotiating with his own digestive system.

There are endless possibilities.

Naturally, I choose the one in which he has recognised me as a fraud.

I can collect a roomful of laughter and still come home preoccupied with one pair of folded arms.

Even the compliments aren’t entirely safe.

“That was wonderful.”

Thank you. Very kind.

“I particularly enjoyed the last story.”

Excellent. Although, now that you mention it, what was wrong with the other ones?

I wouldn’t say that aloud, obviously. I do possess some social skills. But my mind can take a perfectly lovely compliment, dismantle it and build a small instrument of torture with it in mere seconds.

There is value in looking honestly at your work. I want to improve. I want the next audience to get something better because I paid attention to this one.

I also know when reflection stops being useful. Usually because in the wee hours of the morning my brain is examining a half-second pause which may have been too long, at an hour when sensible people are asleep.

I’m not sure I’ve ever been completely happy with a performance.

Pleased, yes. Proud, certainly. There are shows I treasure.

Yet somewhere there’s always a loose thread I want to pull, even when I know I might unravel the entire jumper.

The following morning, that restlessness meets the quiet.

There’s no introduction coming. No audience gathering. No reason to gather myself into that particular version of Calum who steps forward and begins.

There’s breakfast, checkout, a drive. There are messages to answer and things waiting at home.

Ordinary life, carrying on quite reasonably.

I sometimes feel unreasonable for struggling with it.

How do you explain that you miss people you met yesterday? That a room you’ll perhaps never enter again has left a space in you? That you’re grateful for the work and still feel miserable now it’s finished?

I can hear myself describing it and think, “For heaven’s sake, man. You told some stories. Have a sandwich.”

Sometimes a sandwich helps.

Sometimes I need sleep, food and a day in which I don’t expect myself to be interesting.

But there’s a sadness there as well. Something happened that mattered to me, and I can’t go back into it. Even if I tell those stories tomorrow, yesterday’s gathering has gone.

That’s a feeling I carry into the gaps between shows.

At first, a gap can seem welcome. Time to recover. Time to catch up. Time to do the hundred small jobs I’ve been moving from one list to another.

Then the days open out.

I miss the work. I worry about the next booking. I start measuring my usefulness against my schedule, which is a fairly brutal way to assess a human being.

A quiet week begins to feel like a verdict.

I know better, in theory.

In practice, knowing something and feeling it are entirely two different things.

And all of that can happen after a good show.

After a difficult one, well, make yourself comfortable. We could be here a while.

Some performances never quite find their rhythm.

There may be nothing disastrous about them. I turn up prepared. I tell the stories. People listen, perhaps laugh, perhaps thank me afterwards.

But I can feel that I’m working for every inch, its like walking through treacle.

An opening that usually welcomes people, seems to hover between us. A joke falls flat, so I change direction, but the change feels clumsy.

I start watching myself perform.

Now that’s an uncomfortable place to stand: half in the story, half outside it, monitoring whether the man telling it is making a complete arse of himself. (Note to self....he usually is)

I become aware of my hands. My voice. How long I’ve been talking.

And now I’m thinking about whether my arms look natural, the evening has acquired an unnecessarily complicated air and I’m looking at the exits trying to come up with a plan that would make Wile E. Coyote proud. Although Strapping two rockets to my back may not work in the kilt.

Experience helps me keep going. I can make choices, adjust, finish the work. I don’t need to feel wonderful to give people something worthwhile.

But afterwards, the relief of finishing can be swallowed by dread.

Was it as awkward as it felt? Did the organiser notice? Will they book me again?

Then comes the line I know far too well.

“You should know better by now.”

It’s astonishing how quickly I can turn fifteen years of experience into evidence for the prosecution.

I should have read the room sooner. Changed stories. Slowed down. Picked up the pace. Been funnier. Been quieter. Somehow anticipated everything before it happened.

I grant myself very little allowance for being a person working with other people.

I wouldn’t speak to a younger performer that way. If someone came to me after a difficult show, I’d listen. I’d ask what happened. We’d look for something they could use next time.

I wouldn’t tell them one awkward evening had exposed a fundamental flaw in their existence.

Yet apparently that’s acceptable professional development when I’m doing it to myself.

There are things I can learn from a show that doesn’t connect. There are also things I cannot know. I don’t have access to every thought in the room.

That doesn’t prevent me inventing them.

Usually, in my imagination, the organiser has become devastatingly articulate about my shortcomings during the drive home.

Meanwhile, the actual organiser may be looking for a missing cash box or wondering who left half a cake in the kitchen.

I’m quite capable of making myself the centre of a disaster that nobody else knows is happening.

And there are days when I can achieve all this without leaving the house.

Those are the camera days.

I’ve decided to record some stories for social media. A good idea. People need to hear the work. I can’t wait for everyone to wander into a venue and discover me.

So I choose a tale I know well. Something I’ve told many times. I set up the camera, sort out the sound and convince myself this will be straightforward.

A short recording. Nothing ambitious.

An hour, perhaps.

That’s a charming thought. I remember it fondly later.

I press record, look into the lens and open my mouth.

The story has left the building.

I know where it begins. I knew thirty seconds ago. I could have told you while I was making tea.

Now there’s a blank space where the opening should be.

I try again. Get a sentence out. Dislike it immediately. Stop.

Another attempt. This time I make it further, then stumble over a word I’ve been using successfully since childhood.

Stop.

I watch a bit back and discover that I’m apparently doing something extraordinary with my eyebrows.

Why am I looking at the camera like it owes me money?

Now I’m thinking about my face, which does very little to improve my memory.

The more I restart, the more conscious I become of every choice. Where should I look? Is that too much movement? Too little? Why does my perfectly familiar voice sound like someone applying for permission to be Scottish?

A tale I can happily inhabit in front of a crowd becomes a series of sentences I cannot persuade myself to say.

Eventually, I stop finding it funny.

I sit there with the camera waiting, and a colder thought arrives.

What if this isn’t just an awkward recording session?

What if something is wrong?

I know this story. A hundred tellings, perhaps more. How can I suddenly struggle to begin it?

I’m no spring chicken. Is my memory going? Is this the start of something?

My frightened mind can get as far as dementia before the kettle has boiled.

That fear isn’t a diagnosis. A blank moment in front of a lens cannot tell me what’s happening with my health. But in the middle of it, I’m frightened, and fear is very willing to fill in whatever it doesn’t know.

Then the questions broaden.

Perhaps I’ve lost whatever ability I had.

Perhaps I never really had it.

Perhaps I’ve mistaken a loud voice and a kilt for an actual career.

There’s a particularly unpleasant shame in being unable to do, alone in a room, the thing you describe as your profession.

I’m a storyteller.

Splendid. Tell a story, then.

And there I sit.

The camera goes away eventually. Sometimes because I’m tired, sometimes because continuing would only give me more material to punish myself with.

But putting it away doesn’t finish the conversation.

The doubt comes downstairs with me. It sits beside the next task. It’s there when somebody asks whether I managed to get anything recorded.

“Not really,” I say.

Two small words for an afternoon that has somehow shaken the foundations.

Days can pass like that. I know it sounds disproportionate. From the outside, the answer seems obvious: have another go tomorrow.

From the inside, I’m wondering whether tomorrow will confirm everything I’m afraid of.

Perhaps this is the world telling me to get a normal job.

A proper job, as people sometimes call it, with the implication that I’ve spent all these years getting dressed up for an elaborate misunderstanding.

I’ve done other work. I know there’s dignity, skill and difficulty in it. I also know what it feels like to spend my days trying to fit into a life that leaves something important in me unused.

That doesn’t stop the argument.

Bills don’t disappear because I’m having a crisis of artistic identity. A family needs more than a touching explanation of how much storytelling means to me.

The practical worries give the doubts somewhere solid to stand.

That’s when “Who am I?” stops feeling like an interesting philosophical question.

It becomes a weary one.

Who am I if this doesn’t work? Who am I between bookings? Who am I when I can’t get a familiar tale out of my mouth?

Eventually, something usually interrupts the spiral.

Sometimes it’s another show. Sometimes a conversation. Sometimes I simply remember what actually happens when I tell stories to people.

I look at them.

That sounds terribly obvious, but it matters.

I’ve spent years learning to work with what comes back. A smile tells me something. So does uncertainty. I hear the difference between a room waiting and a room wandering away.

I respond almost without thinking. Give a moment more space. Offer a detail. Let a character look at someone. Find my way through with the people who are there.

When I’m recording alone, so much of that is missing.

The wee round lens gives me nothing.

No warmth. No surprise. No indication that it understands why an elderly woman has just threatened a supernatural creature with something from her kitchen.

It doesn’t even have the courtesy to look offended.

I’m waiting for a response from an object designed to capture one.

When I remember that, I can breathe a little.

I haven’t suddenly forgotten that an audience exists. I’m struggling to work without the exchange that helps me tell.

Recording asks me to develop another way of reaching someone. There’s a person beyond that lens, eventually, but I can’t see them yet.

I have to learn how to trust that.

Sometimes imagining one person helps. Someone who would enjoy the tale. Someone I can speak to instead of trying to entertain an invisible population while scrutinising my own forehead.

Sometimes I need to finish a telling without stopping at every stumble.

Sometimes the most useful thing I can do is leave it alone and come back when I’m less exhausted.

None of this promises an easy afternoon. It gives me something to try besides declaring myself finished.

And I need that distinction, because I’ve confused difficulty with a final verdict often enough.

I’d love to tell you this confession ends with a great revelation. That I’ve made peace with myself and now float serenely between performances, recording delightful videos whenever the mood takes me.

I haven’t.

This is what goes on in my head every day, week and year, in one shape or another. Some days it’s background muttering. Other days it gets the best chair and insists on running the household.

I can know I’m capable and still be afraid I’m not.

I can love a performance and dismantle it afterwards.

I can recognise the camera problem and still sit down tomorrow wondering why the words won’t come.

There’s no tidy finish to offer. I’m in the middle of it.

I’m trying, though, to give the good things a fair hearing.

If I’m willing to remember one awkward silence for years, perhaps I can also remember the faces that lit up. The conversations afterwards. The times I felt a room come with me and knew we were sharing something worth having.

Those happened too.

I don’t have to mistrust every good moment simply because it speaks more quietly than the doubt.

I think part of the trouble is how visible confidence looks from the outside.

People see a man comfortable enough to walk into a gathering, make a bit of noise and invite everyone along. They see the jokes, the ease, the willingness to look ridiculous if the moment calls for it.

They don’t see what happens when I’m alone afterwards.

I understand why. I’m there to give them an evening, and I want to give it wholeheartedly. They haven’t bought a ticket to supervise my internal weather.

Still, it can feel strange to be described as a natural when you know how much wrestling goes on behind the scenes. I remember being frightened of attention. I remember wanting somewhere to hide. The fact that I can stand up now doesn’t mean that earlier version of me has packed his bags.

Sometimes he’s right there, waiting until the room empties.

I suspect I’ve expected confidence to become permanent if I just gather enough experience. As though one day I’ll reach the correct number of performances and receive a certificate declaring me free from doubt.

Preferably laminated. Something sturdy to wave at myself on difficult mornings.

It hasn’t arrived.

What has arrived is enough experience to know I’ve survived these feelings before. I’ve had the dreadful afternoon, the quiet week, the show I couldn’t stop picking apart. Afterwards, I’ve found myself laughing with an audience again.

Remembering that doesn’t always change how I feel immediately. But it can keep me from making a permanent decision while I’m tired and frightened.

I can leave the question unanswered for an evening. Sleep. Talk to someone. Let the next day arrive before deciding what the rest of my life must mean.

That’s a smaller ambition than conquering self-doubt.

On some days, it’s quite enough.

And perhaps I can be Calum on the quiet days without producing evidence that I deserve the name.

A tired man can have breakfast. A storyteller can struggle with a story. I’m trying to allow myself that much room.

There will be another gathering, I hope. Another moment when I look out, find a face, and begin.

For a while, I’ll forget to ask who I am.

I’ll be too busy telling.

The morning after may still find me tired, blue and taking the evening apart over disappointing coffee.

But before I put my whole existence on trial, I should probably eat something.

Assuming, of course, breakfast is included.


 
 
 

1 Comment


ucmagic
6 days ago

Loved this. It was like looking at myself in the mirror. Well articulated mate. Thanks

Like

CALUM LYKAN 

STORYTELLING 

WEAVER OF DREAMS, SLAYER OF BOREDOM

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

​Trademark 2011 Calum Lykan Storytelling (TM). All Right Reserved. Website by Calum Lykan Storytelling. New Brunswick, Canada

bottom of page